50 Corporate Park, Irvine, CA 92606
Toll-Free 1(800) 542-0900
CASE STUDY

McKinney, Koller, et al. v. Consumer Reports, Inc.

San Diego County Superior Court

Case No. 37-2020-00046677-CU-BT-CTL

Case Type
Consumer
Deliverability Rate
99.6%
Settlement Fund
$1,150,000

Case Type

Deliverability Rate

Settlement Fund

Consumer
99.6%
$1,150,000

Case Background

The settlement addressed allegations that Consumer Reports, Inc. improperly enrolled California consumers into automatic-renewal or continuous-service subscriptions—covering its magazine, online access, and other products—between March 2, 2016, and November 5, 2020. Consumers claimed that the automatic renewals were effectuated without adequate disclosure of the terms or clear consent, in violation of California’s consumer-protection laws. The parties agreed to a $1.15 million settlement to resolve the claims across the defined class.

Our Goal

CPT Group was retained to administer the settlement with precision and transparency: ensuring that the 279,250 class‐member records were promptly validated, accurately contacted, and appropriately guided through the claims process. The objective was to maximize the reach and accessibility of the notice program and to support high-quality participation rates while upholding the integrity of the administration process.

The CPT Group Solution

CPT Group leveraged its scalable infrastructure and data-validation expertise to manage the large consumer class. Starting with more than 279,250 records, CPT conducted extensive skip-tracing and National Change of Address (NCOA) validation to refine contact accuracy. The administration team mailed and emailed notices, and dispatched reminder emails to those who had not filed a claim by the designated deadline. To ensure a seamless claims experience, CPT launched a custom interactive website where class members could submit claims securely and review case information in real time. The combination of robust data workflows, diversified notice channels (mail, email, web), and user-friendly online infrastructure underpinned the campaign’s success.

Results

CPT achieved an exceptional notice outcome: delivering notice to 278,154 Class Members, representing a 99.6% deliverability rate. In total, 10,788 valid claims were submitted, for a valid claims rate of 3.88%—outperforming typical benchmarks for consumer settlement participation. The multi-channel strategy reaffirmed CPT Group’s reputation for operational excellence, data-driven outreach, and class-member accessibility.

Key Metrics

Settlement Fund
$1.15 Million
Total Class Members
279,250
Deliverability Rate
99.6%
Class Members Notified
278,154
Valid Claims Received
10,788
Valid Claims Rate
3.88%
Notice Methods
Mail, Email, Web, Reminder Email
Data Validation Efforts
Skip-Tracing, NCOA

Visual Summary

CONTACT US

CPT Group can simplify your Class Action Administration

We’ve been a trusted leader in class action administration since 1984 — appointed by major courts to manage over 7,000 cases, serve more than 250 million class members, and disburse billions in settlements.

REQUEST A QUOTE
CONTACT US

CPT Group can simplify your Class Action Administration

We’ve been a trusted leader in class action administration since 1984 — appointed by major courts to manage over 7,000 cases, serve more than 250 million class members, and disburse billions in settlements.

REQUEST A QUOTE